Permit Panic, Positioning Reset
AI data center permitting fears are washing out investor positioning.
The NAAIM Exposure Index dropped from nearly 88 to below 73 in three weeks.
Similar readings have historically led to above-average S&P 500 returns.
Sometimes the best thing that can happen to a boom is a speed limit...
The AI trade has hit a pothole. Investors are worried the data center build-out is running into a wall of local pushback. The latest jolt came from Texas, one of the busiest data center markets in the country, where Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has pledged to pause data center approvals until state lawmakers pass new rules. The S&P 500 has slipped about 6% since early October, dragging it right back to its 200-day moving average for the first time since the spring...

But there’s a detail the headlines are skipping. Before the election, she said her pause would apply to new permits. Projects that are already approved and under construction are hard to stop midstream, and they should keep the build-out moving through 2027 and 2028. That gets us to the next election cycle, and the outcome there could look very different. It could even swing back toward more support.
And here's the twist: a meter on the build-out may not be a bad thing. If new capacity comes online more slowly, compute capacity stays in check. Meanwhile, companies like Nvidia keep talking up demand. When demand keeps rising and supply is capped, pricing goes up.
That shift could lift margins, profits, and free cash flow all along the AI chain — from the chipmakers to the cloud providers renting out capacity. Yet sentiment and positioning are getting washed out, with active money managers stepping back as if the boom is over. That leaves them under-allocated just as higher profits could push up earnings estimates for the S&P 500 Index. History shows that’s the kind of setup that underpins a steady, long-term rally.
But don't take my word for it, let's look at what the data's telling us...
One of the easiest ways to see how professional investors are positioned is through the National Association of Active Investment Managers ("NAAIM") Exposure Index. It captures where money managers are sitting in U.S. equities. Institutions can be anywhere from fully short (-200%) to fully leveraged long (+200%). The gauge distills it into a single number.
Because it reflects real allocations rather than opinions, it gives a direct read on how much risk money managers are willing to carry at any moment. Rising exposure means they're leaning in. Falling exposure means they're stepping back, hedging, or simply waiting for the dust to settle.
The index becomes especially revealing at the extremes. When exposure surges, managers are already fully committed to the trend, leaving little dry powder if conditions wobble. When exposure collapses, fear is usually well-priced and sellers are largely spent. It's not a timing tool, but it reliably shows when positioning has swung too far and the rubber band is stretched.
Over the past year, that rubber band has stayed stretched. The NAAIM Index topped 100 twice — in late October and mid-December of last year — and spent much of 2026 in the 80s and 90s. Its one-year average still sits near 85. But that posture is starting to crack...

The latest reading fell to 72.9, its lowest level since mid-September. That's a 16.9% drop from 87.69 just three weeks earlier — a meaningful shift from "all-in" to "dial it back." It also puts the index within striking distance of its long-term average of 67.6...

So, I wanted to go back and look at prior episodes where we've seen a similar drop. Historically, the gauge has fallen below its long-term average roughly 30% of the time. As the chart above shows, those moments tend to cluster around stress points: the COVID shock in 2020, the Fed's tightening cycle in 2022, and Liberation Day in 2025.
From there, I pulled the S&P 500's forward returns following every reading of 70 or lower — right around where we are now. I looked at both price returns and total returns (dividends reinvested). What I found was that across the board, the index tended to deliver above-average gains.
Here are the price basis numbers...

One year out, the S&P 500 has averaged a 10.1% gain versus its long-term annualized 7.2% since 1928, with a 78.3% success rate. The results are even better two years out, with a 23.6% gain and an 82.3% success rate.
But the total return numbers are even better...

The 12-month total return numbers stand out with a 12.1% average gain and an 80.5% success rate. The 24-month results are even better, with a 28.4% average increase and an 84.7% success rate. Both are well ahead of the S&P 500's long-term 9.7% annualized total return.
And here's where it gets interesting. The index last sat at 70 or below for five straight weeks in March and April. None of those signals has reached its one-year mark yet, but here's how they stand through Wednesday's close...

Even after the recent pullback, every one of those signals is in the green, with an average gain of 10.4%. That's already ahead of the S&P 500's long-term annual pace, with four to five months still left on the one-year clock.
The toughest stretches for investors tend to be when the narrative turns dark, and the loudest voices insist the sky is falling. Today, it's data center permits. As a result, sentiment and positioning are getting washed out. That's also when the NAAIM Exposure Index shows active managers at their most defensive. They pull back just as fear peaks. Yet historically, those resets have marked the moments when future returns quietly improve. There's no reason to assume this setup will behave any differently.
Five Stories Moving the Market:
Anthropic and its seven co-founders have raised $107.3 billion in an upsized IPO and private placement, becoming the first frontier AI lab tapping the public markets to fund its development of thinking machines – Bloomberg. (Why you should care - the raise takes Anthropic’s cash pile from about $132 billion to roughly $230 billion; that’s enough to cover more than three years’ worth of its next-12-month compute bills, which eases worries about how it pays for its spending commitments and supports the chip and cloud names on the other side of those contract)
Cybersecurity firm Palo Alto Networks raised its annual revenue forecast and agreed to acquire AI startup Applied Compute for $4.5 billion, as a heightened threat environment pushes customers toward broader security products; Palo Alto now expects fiscal 2027 revenue to be between $14.52 billion and $14.57 billion, compared with its prior expectation of $14.10 billion to $14.20 billion – Reuters. (Why you should care - customers are spending more on cybersecurity as threats increase, which supports earnings estimates across the security software group; the Applied Compute deal also shows big cybersecurity companies paying up to add AI)
Federal Reserve officials who held interest rates steady last month thought higher rates would still be needed to bring down inflation; the minutes of the latest U.S. central bank meeting indicated that a number of officials, who are not monetary policy voters, supported another interest rates hike – WSJ. (Why you should care – the statement likely supports an additional rate hike at the upcoming FOMC meeting in December)
Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco President Mary Daly said further interest rate increases are needed but the U.S. central bank should take a measured approach to tightening policy as it assess how the economy is evolving – Bloomberg. (Why you should care – Daly backs more rate hikes but at a slower pace, which points to a gradual tightening path rather than an aggressive one; that matters more than usual because she becomes a voting member of the Fed’s rate committee next year)
Federal Reserve Governor Michael Barr said he’s likely to be on board with tighter monetary policy in an economy still beset by inflation pressures; Barr noted that while inflation is an issue, the economy is otherwise doing well – Reuters. (Why you should care – Barr is a governor, so he votes at every meeting; his openness to tighter policy raises the odds of a rate hike at the December meeting, and his view that the economy is otherwise doing well tells you the Fed thinks it has room to keep pushing)
Economic Calendar:
Earnings: WMT, WSM, INTU, ROST, KEYS, CPRT
Switzerland - Trade Balance for October (2 a.m.)
Eurozone - Current Account for September (4 a.m.)
ECB's Elderson (Executive Board Member) Speaks (5 a.m.)
Eurozone - Construction Output for September (5 a.m.)
U.K. - CBI Industrial Trends Orders for November (6 a.m.)
BoE's Dhingra (MPC Member) Speaks (7:15 a.m.)
U.S. - Initial Jobless Claims (8:30 a.m.)
U.S. - Continuing Claims (8:30 a.m.)
U.S. - Philadelphia Fed Manufacturing Index for November (8:30 a.m.)
Canada - Industrial Product and Raw Materials Price Indexes for October (8:30 a.m.)
ECB's Lagarde (President) Speaks (8:30 a.m.)
Fed's Jefferson (Board, Vice Chair) Speaks (9:25 a.m.)
U.S. - Leading Index for October (10 a.m.)
U.S. - Kansas City Fed Manufacturing Index for November (11 a.m.)
Fed's Goolsbee (Chicago, Non-Voter) Speaks (12:30 p.m.)
Treasury Auctions $19 Billion in 10-Year TIPS (1 p.m.)
Fed's Barkin (Richmond, Non-Voter) Speaks (2 p.m.)
Fed's Barr (Board, Voter) Speaks (2:15 p.m.)
Fed's Balance Sheet Update (4:30 p.m.)
Japan - CPI for October (6:30 p.m.)
U.K. - GfK Consumer Confidence for November (7:01 p.m.)
PBoC - Loan Prime Rate Decision (8:15 p.m.)



Comments