A Speed Limit, Not a Dead End
AAII investor sentiment sank back into deeply negative territory last week.
The bull versus bear spread dropped to -20.6.
History says readings like this tend to precede above-average S&P 500 gains.
Bull markets rarely end in a wave of fear - they die of euphoria...
Since the midterm results came in, the market's newest worry has a name: AI. With control of Congress changing hands, a number of the winning candidates are on record backing tighter rules, or even a moratorium, on new data centers. The shift caused investors to sell first and ask questions later. The S&P 500 Index fell 4.4% on Thursday, November 5, its worst day since April 2025, as chip and data center names led the way lower.
Here's the thing: the fear looks overblown. No bill has passed, and the new Congress won't be seated until January. More importantly, guardrails aren't a stop sign. If lawmakers move to meter the pace of data center construction, the likeliest outcome is a buildout that grows at a steady clip rather than a runaway one.

And that's not a bad thing. A steadier pace stretches the spending cycle out over more years instead of front-loading it. And cycles that run longer tend to end later. It also keeps computing capacity tight relative to demand, which supports pricing for the hyperscalers. A steady build plus firm pricing is a recipe for durable revenue and earnings growth.
In other words, the market may be treating a speed limit like a dead end. And individual investors are leading the retreat. Based on the data I’ve surveyed, similar scenarios in the past have tended to lead to above-average stock market gains over the following two years. That should underpin a steady rally in the S&P 500 Index.
But don't take my word for it, let's look at what the data's telling us...
Some of the market's most useful signals are easy to miss in the weekly noise. One just flashed again. The American Association of Individual Investors' ("AAII") Bull-Bear Spread fell to -20.6 last week, with bears at 51.4% and bulls at just 30.8%. That's a sharp slide from -14.3 the week before. It might read like a footnote, but historically it's been a reliable turning point in sentiment, and a tailwind for forward returns.

Here's why it matters. Each week, AAII asks individual investors whether they're bullish, bearish, or neutral on stocks over the next six months. Week to week, the readings bounce around. But when pessimists badly outnumber optimists, it usually signals emotional exhaustion. Investors have already braced for the worst. And once that selling dries up, there isn't much left to push prices lower.
Since the start of 2000, the spread has crossed below -20 a total of 68 times. That's rare enough to matter, yet frequent enough to test. And the follow-through has been hard to ignore...

A year after the signal, the S&P 500 has climbed an average of 15.1% on a price basis, with a median gain of 17.4%. That's nearly double the gauge's 8.1% average annual gain since 1928. The hit rate stands out, too. Of the 65 signals with a full year of data, 80% ended higher. Stretch it to two years, and 87.3% of the 63 completed cases were positive, with a gain of 28.8%.
Those aren't statistical quirks. They're what happens when sentiment gets stretched too far in one direction and snaps back.
We've watched it play out in real time. The September 10, 2025, signal arrived amid inflation jitters, geopolitical tension, and soft earnings revisions. Twelve months later, the S&P 500 was up 16.2%. This year has followed the same script. The spread broke below -20 on March 18, and the index has rallied 14.1% since. It flashed again on September 16, and even after this month's AI scare, the S&P 500 sits slightly above that level. Through Friday, the index is up 10.5% year to date and just 3.3% below its October 6 record high.
Now we have a third signal for 2026. It's too early to measure the payoff, but the setup looks familiar: a scary headline, a sharp selloff, and individual investors heading for the exits, while the fundamentals underneath, from spending to pricing to earnings, stay intact. That combination has typically been fertile ground for gains.
Bottom line: when the AAII Bull-Bear Spread has sunk this low, it's often marked the start of strong equity performance over the next one to two years. No signal is perfect, and history never guarantees the future. But today's AI fears look more like a speed bump than a wall. A metered buildout likely means a longer cycle, firmer pricing, and steadier earnings growth for the hyperscalers. Fear eventually exhausts itself, and markets tend to grind higher. For long-term investors, these are the moments that matter.
Five Stories Moving the Market:
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland President Beth Hammack said she favors small and steady increases in interest rates, but the central bank may need to consider larger moves if inflation pressures worsen – Bloomberg. (Why you should care – Hammack, who is the most hawkish policymaker, is likely to support a rate hike at the upcoming FOMC meeting in December)
PJM Interconnection, the largest U.S. grid operator, asked federal regulators to approve a plan that would cut the time to connect new power plants and data centers to the grid in half, from two years to 12 months, by combining its separate reviews of generation, transmission and large power users into one process, though data center companies may have to pay a bigger share of grid upgrade costs - Reuters. (Why you should care - faster connections should keep the data center buildout moving, but the fix may come a bit late, as data center companies are increasingly turning to their own power supplies)
Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh said artificial intelligence could push productivity and GDP growth well above their long-run averages, while stressing that the central bank isn’t making predictions; he laid out three illustrative Board staff scenarios: broad-based gains with full employment, strong growth with job displacement and higher unemployment, or a disappointment where returns on the AI spending fall short, valuations drop and the economy slows – Federal Reserve. (Why you should care - Warsh is signaling that the Fed is now formally modeling AI’s effects on growth, jobs, and asset prices, to be better prepared with the most appropriate monetary policy down the road)
Minutes of the Reserve Bank of Australia’s November 2-3 board meeting showed six of the nine members assessed policy tightening this year was not “clearly sufficient” to address inflation risks given the potential rise in the neutral rate and how sticky inflation has been – Reuters. (Why you should care – the commentary implies the RBA likely isn’t done raising interest rates)
The Commerce Department issued an interim rule requiring data center operators in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, and Brazil to get a U.S. license before exporting advanced AI chips from Nvidia and other American manufacturers, aiming to block China from reaching U.S. computing power through offshore data centers – Bloomberg. (Why you should care - the proposed rule likely does little to restrict access in practice, so the selloff in chip stocks looks like an overreaction rather than a real hit to AI demand)
Economic Calendar:
Earnings: HD, DIS, NVDA
U.K. - Unemployment Rate for September (2 a.m.)
U.K. - Average Earnings for September (2 a.m.)
U.K. - Claimant Count Change for October (2 a.m.)
Germany - ZEW Economic Sentiment for November (5 a.m.)
Eurozone - ZEW Economic Sentiment for November (5 a.m.)
European Commission - Economic Forecasts (5 a.m.)
U.S. - ADP Weekly Employment Change (8:15 a.m.)
Canada - Housing Starts for October (8:15 a.m.)
U.S. - Retail Sales for October (8:30 a.m.)
U.S. - Import and Export Prices for October (8:30 a.m.)
Fed's Waller (Board, Voter) Speaks (9:10 a.m.)
U.S. - Industrial Production and Capacity Utilization for October (9:15 a.m.)
U.S. - Business Inventories for September (10 a.m.)
U.S. - NAHB Housing Market Index for November (10 a.m.)
Treasury Auctions $100 Billion in 6-Week Bills (11:30 a.m.)
ECB's Lane (Chief Economist) Speaks (1:30 p.m.)
Fed's Williams (New York, Voter) Speaks (2:25 p.m.)
U.S. - American Petroleum Institute Crude Oil Inventory Data (4:30 p.m.)
RBA's Bullock (Governor) Speaks (6 p.m.)
Japan - Trade Balance for October (6:50 p.m.)
Australia - Wage Price Index for Q3 (7:30 p.m.)
Bundesbank's Nagel (President) Speaks (9:45 p.m.)



Comments